Memory Foam or Pocket Spring Mattresses: Which is Better?

When it comes to choosing a mattress, you’ve likely wondered: is memory foam as revolutionary as it claims, or does the reliable pocket spring still have the edge? Each mattress type brings its own unique benefits, and the right choice can drastically impact your sleep quality. From the pressure-relieving contours of memory foam to the sturdy support of pocket springs, knowing what each has to offer is key to finding the perfect fit for your sleep needs. Let’s break down their differences and help you make the best choice for the restful, rejuvenating sleep you deserve.

What’s the Difference?

When choosing between a pocket spring mattress and a memory foam mattress, the key difference lies in how each provides support and comfort. Let’s take a look at how they differ: 

Pocket Spring Mattresses 

A pocket spring mattress is what most people think of when they imagine a traditional mattress—though it's had some modern upgrades. Instead of interconnected springs, pocket mattresses feature individual coils that are each wrapped in their own fabric pocket. This design allows the springs to move independently, meaning the mattress adapts more precisely to your body shape. The result? Better support for pressure points like your hips and shoulders, and less disruption if your partner moves during the night​.

Memory Foam Mattresses 

Memory foam mattresses have a completely different approach to comfort and support. Instead of using springs, memory foam relies on layers of dense foam that respond to your body heat and weight. As you lie down, the foam gently contours to your unique shape, offering pressure relief by evenly distributing your weight across the mattress. This creates that classic "hugging" sensation that memory foam is known for. One of the standout features is how well it isolates motion—so if your partner tends to toss and turn, you won’t feel those movements on your side of the bed​.

The Key Differences:

• Support System:
• Pocket Spring: Utilises individual springs encased in fabric pockets, which respond independently to your body, offering targeted support where it’s needed most.
• Memory Foam: Uses layers of dense foam that contour to your body, distributing your weight evenly across the surface for pressure relief.
• Motion Isolation:
• Pocket Spring: Minimises motion transfer better than traditional spring mattresses, but not as effectively as memory foam.
• Memory Foam: Excellent at absorbing movement, making it ideal for couples who don’t want to be disturbed by their partner’s movements.
• Comfort and Feel:
• Pocket Spring: Provides a more traditional, bouncy feel with a balance of firmness and cushioning.
• Memory Foam: Offers a “sinking” or “hugging” sensation as it conforms to the body’s curves, creating a softer feel.
• Temperature Control:
• Pocket Spring: Generally cooler due to the air circulation between the springs, making it a good choice for hot sleepers.
• Memory Foam: This can trap heat, though many models now include cooling technologies like gel or open-cell foam to improve airflow.
• Durability:
• Pocket Spring: Known for its durability, often lasting longer without sagging, especially in high-quality models.
• Memory Foam: Typically has a lifespan of 6–8 years, as the foam can soften and lose its ability to bounce back over time.

Which Option Does Teddy Offer? 

At teddy, we’re all about creating a dreamy sleep experience tailored to you. However, we do lean towards memory foam, with our iDream and Teddy Junior Lux mattresses offering the kind of luxurious, pressure-relieving comfort that makes you feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud. If you love that cosy, “hugged” sensation, these foam mattresses are just the ticket.

But if you want the best of both worlds—support and softness—look no further than the iDream Elite. This hybrid mattress brings together the contouring magic of KloudFlex™ Memory Foam with the responsive support of micro-coil pocket springs. 

Teddy’s Mattress Quiz

Choosing the right mattress should be a fun process - that’s why we’ve created this helpful quiz! Keep note of whether you answer mostly A’s or B’s to reveal your perfect match.

1. How do you feel when you sink into bed?

• A: I love feeling like I’m melting into a cosy cloud.
• B: I want a bit of bounce when I lie down, like a soft trampoline.

• A: I need my mattress to cradle every curve, especially my hips and shoulders.
• B: I prefer firm, even support that keeps my back aligned and feels sturdy.

• A: I can’t stand feeling every time my partner moves—it's like a wave!
• B: My bed traps heat, and I end up tossing off the blankets just to stay cool.

• A: I’m good as long as I’m comfortable and cosy.
• B: Absolutely—I can’t stand feeling hot and sticky during the night.

• A: Softness. I like my mattress to feel plush and cosy.
• B: Airflow. I tend to sleep hot and want to stay cool.

• A: Mostly on my side.
• B: On my back or stomach.

Mostly A’s: Memory Foam 
You’re all about the memory foam experience. If you crave that deep, body-hugging comfort and hate being woken up by your partner moving, memory foam is your go-to. It’s perfect for side sleepers, too, as it cushions your body’s curves and gives you that luxurious, sink-in feel. Plus, modern memory foam is starting to tackle heat retention with cooling technologies, so it’s not all about warmth anymore!

Mostly B’s: Pocket Spring 

If you got more B’s, you’re likely someone who loves the classic, reliable feel of a pocket spring mattress. You want support that keeps you cool and slightly elevated, with just the right amount of bounce. Pocket springs are great for back and stomach sleepers, giving you that firm, breathable surface to keep your sleep cool and comfortable all night long.

Made your Decision? 

Whether you’ve fallen for the cradling comfort of memory foam or you’re leaning towards the breathable bounce of coils, teddy has a mattress to fit your sleep style perfectly. If you need more personalised advice or have any questions, our friendly team is here to help you choose the best option for your needs.